For dinner tonight, Chris and I decided to make some Alfredo sauce. After some online digging, Chris found a recipe that was a 1:1 ratio unsalted butter and parmesan (which, on a side note, doesn’t come from a green can. or a red can. or any can). We ended up using 6 ounces of each, although for 2oz of cheese, we used pecorino romano. We mixed these at room temperature until it had formed a paste. We used 1lb of pasta, and a good ladle full (1/2-1 cup) of the pasta water in the sauce as well. It turned out very different from any restaurant style alfredo sauce we’d had, and exceptionally rich and filling.
It has pecorino. How could it go wrong?
I agree – though I suspect the purist would cry foul. Personally, I like pecorino romano better than parmigiano, because of its sharper flavour and slightly higher salt content.
That said, it probably violates some rule of something or other. 🙂
I have to say this was a very different experience than the typical state-side cream alfredo sauces that have heavy cream and nutmeg in them. Giada’s book “Everyday Italian” has an alfredo recipe with heavy cream, a little lemon zest, and a touch of nutmeg in it.
She says the cream addition is a modification because American butter and the Parmigiano originally available weren’t rich enough – e.g., not enough butterfat. I think this is not the case anymore.
Personally, I think the heavy cream and nutmeg allow a person to cheat on the amount of parmigiano used, thus cutting costs. The nutmeg helps to give the slightly nutty flavour of the parmigiano, or so it is hoped. I honestly think that if I wanted to make newburg, I’d make newburg. No nutmeg or cream for me, thanks.